David James -White Christmas 2026 (Phil Davis) Helen Hayes nominations: Spamalot (Character Man), Pirates… (Sergeant of Police), The Wizard of Oz (Scarecrow – HH Winner!), Godspell (HH Winner!), The Addams Family (Grandma). Toby’s credits include: Little Shop of Horrors (Seymour), Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (Cogsworth), Les Misérables (Thenardier), Young Frankenstein [...]
Margaret Kelly
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T01:30:51+00:00Margaret Kaider -White Christmas 2026 (Swing) Thrilled to be back at Toby's! Danced competitively and trained in Royal Academy of Ballet syllabi for 18 years. Graduated Summa Cum Laude in Criminal Justice from Pace University. Toby's: Elf (Swing),Saturday Night Fever (Linda Manero/Ensemble), Disney’s The Little Mermaid (Swing). Thanks to family, friends, [...]
Nicky Kaider
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T01:35:29+00:00Nicky Kaider -White Christmas 2026 (Ensemble) Nicky is excited to share the stage with his wife, Margaret Kaider, in White Christmas! Toby’s: Jersey Boys (Frankie Valli – Helen Hayes Nomination Outstanding Lead Performer); Olney: Some Like It Hot (Ensemble). Nicky thanks his loving family and friends for all of their tremendous [...]
Amanda Kaplan-Landstrom
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T03:24:37+00:00Amanda Kaplan-Landstrom -White Christmas 2026 (Ensemble) Toby’s credits: Mean Girls, The Wizard of Oz, Elf, The Music Man, The Addams Family, A Chorus Line, Sister Act, Something Rotten, The SpongeBob Musical, Spamalot, South Pacific, Hairspray, Gypsy. Olney: On The Town, The Producers, Guys & Dolls, Mary Poppins. Love to David and [...]
Shawn Kettering
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T01:45:33+00:00Shawn Kettering -White Christmas 2026 (Jimmy, Ezekiel Foster) Credits include: The Addams Family (Uncle Fester), The Music Man (Mercellus), Spamalot (Sir Bedevere), Fiddler on the Roof (Perchik), Seussical (Horton), A Year With Frog and Toad (Frog), The Buddy Holly Story (Big Bopper), Grease (Sonny), Joseph... (Pharoah), Happy Days (Howard Cunningham) and [...]
Alexis Krey- Bedore
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T01:49:06+00:00Alexis Krey- Bedore -White Christmas 2026 (Rhoda) Toby’s credits include: Mean Girls (Karen), Rock of Ages, Disney’s Beauty and the Beast, A Chorus Line (Val), Escape to Margaritaville, Shrek, The SpongeBob Musical, Spamalot. Olney Theatre: Kinky Boots; Cumberland Theatre: Reefer Madness (Mary Lane) and Gypsy (June). Washington Capitals NHL Cheerleader for [...]
Lily Martin
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T03:21:09+00:00Lily Martin -White Christmas 2026 (Susan) Lily is thrilled to return to Toby’s, last seen in The Music Man (Amaryllis). Recent credits include Silhouette Stages: Matilda; CCTA: School of Rock, Annie, Alice in Wonderland, The Wizard of Oz, and her school production of Aladdin. Love to all who let me sing [...]
Ellie May Sennett
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T02:08:45+00:00Ellie May Sennett -White Christmas 2026 (Susan) Excited to be returning to Toby's in White Christmas! Most recently Ellie was seen as The Little Girl in Lincoln Center Theater's Tony Award winning production of Ragtime. Previous roles also include Toby's Dinner Theatre’s The Music Man (Amaryllis). Thanks to family and friends [...]
Jeffrey Shankle
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T03:19:05+00:00Jeffrey Shankle -White Christmas 2026 (Bob Wallace) 2024 Helen Hayes winner for Something Rotten (Nick Bottom). Toby’s Credits: The Wizard of Oz (Tin Man), The Music Man (Harold Hill), The Sound of Music (Captain Von Trapp), 1776 (John Adams), Shrek (Lord Farquaad - Helen Hayes nomination), Elf (Buddy). He has performed [...]
Emily Signor
Cheryl Clemens-Everidge2026-11-09T03:19:42+00:00Emily Signor -White Christmas 2026 (Ensemble) Grateful to be returning to the Toby’s stage! Toby’s: The Wizard of Oz (Dorothy), The Sound of Music (Liesl – Helen Hayes Nomination); Way Off Broadway Dinner Theatre: How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (Rosemary). BFA Musical Theatre from Ohio Northern University, 2024. [...]