Tina Marie Desimone -Disney's The Little Mermaid 2025 (u/s Ursula) Tina is thrilled to be returning to the Toby’s stage. Most recent Toby’s credits: Something Rotten, It’s a Wonderful Life (Aunt Tillie), Sister Act, Godspell, Mamma Mia (Rosie), Gypsy (Mazeppa). As always, love to her Family & Rock Star nieces: Lily [...]

Joey Ellinghaus -ELF The Musical 2025 (Ensemble) Recent Toby’s credits: Saturday Night Fever (Joey), Disney’s The Little Mermaid (Jetsam), The Music Man, 9to5 (Josh), The Addams Family, Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville, Grease (Sonny), The SpongeBob Musical (Plankton), and Monty Python’s Spamalot (Patsy–2023 HH Winner for Outstanding Supporting Performer). Thank you [...]

Crystal Freeman GHOST- The Musical 2022 (Clara/Ortisha Jones) Some recent credits at Toby’s include The SpongeBob Musical (Mrs. Puff), Rocky, Godspell, Dreamgirls (Effie), A Christmas Carol (Mrs. Fezziwig), In the Heights (Abuela Claudia), Shrek (Dragon). Morgan State University, BA Music. I dedicate this to Mack and Sky.

Noah Graham Noah Graham (Tiny Tim), a 3rd grader, loves to perform!  Credits include: Beauty & the Beast Jr., Aladdin Jr., Charlie Brown & High School Musical Jr.  Hobbies include Tae Kwon Do, painting, soccer, electric guitar, all things “dolphin”, movie nights, and playing with his brother, friends and pets. [...]

Andrew Horn -Disney's Beauty and the Beast 2024 (Maurice U/S) Andrew has performed at Toby’s for over 35 years in over 75 productions. His favorite roles have been in It’s a Wonderful Life (Uncle Billy),  A Christmas Carol (Jacob Marley), Ragtime (Grandfather),  The Sound of Music (Uncle Max), and Oklahoma (Pa Carnes). -It's [...]

David James -ELF The Musical 2025 (Mr. Greenway, u/s Walter Hobbs) Helen Hayes nominations: Spamalot (Character Man), Pirates… (Sergeant of Police), The Wizard of Oz (Scarecrow – HH Winner!), Godspell (HH Winner!), The Addams Family (Grandma). Toby’s credits include: Little Shop of Horrors (Seymour), Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (Cogsworth), White Christmas (Phil), Les [...]

Jennifer Kohlafer Jen Kohlhafer (Swing) is thrilled to be back! She works for AA Co Schools & is a dance teacher at Design in Motion. Toby’s credits include: White Christmas, Hairspray, & West Side Story. She thanks family & friends for the love and support & especially Eric. “I couldn’t have [...]

Darren McDonnell The SpongeBob Musical 2022 (Squidward Q. Tentacles) Toby’s credits: Spamalot (Sir Robin -  2015 Helen Hayes Nomination) Mamma Mia (Harry Bright), 1776 (John Dickinson), The Addams Family (Mal Beineke). Regional credits: Anything Goes (US National Tour), Disaster the Musical (Tony - Cockpit), Arsenic and Old Lace (Mortimer - Cockpit), [...]

Lawrence B. Munsey Lawrence B. Munsey (Maurice/D’Arque U/S) Toby’s credits include: Hairspray (Edna), Into the Woods (Wolf/Father), 1776 (John Hancock), The Addams Family (Gomez), Spamalot (King Arthur), & Les Misérables (Javert). He has costumed, directed, & performed for Toby’s for many years!

Mackenzie Newbury Mackenzie Newbury (Old Hag/Christmas Future/Ens) is happy to be back after being seen in South Pacific last winter. Area credits include Catch Me if You Can (Brenda Strong), City of Angels (Mallory/Avril), Silence! The Musical (Dream Clarice), 42nd Street and Oklahoma!