Caroline Otchet Biography coming soon...

Lilianna Robinson LILIANNA ROBINSON (Susan) is excited to perform in her second Toby’s production. She was previously seen as Zuzu in It’s a Wonderful Life. She has also performed in CCTA’s production of Pippin, as well as Glenelg High School’s Seussical and The Music Man. Lilianna is in the 4th grade [...]

Matthew Schleigh It's A Wonderful Life 2015- (George Bailey) is grateful to reprise this role from 9 years ago! Toby’s credits: The Buddy Holly Story, Ragtime, West Side Story, Damn Yankees. DC area credits: Everyman, Ford’s, Shakespeare, Olney,  and Constellation Theatres, Imagination Stage, and others. Training: Catholic University, London Dramatic Academy. [...]

Jeffrey Shankle -GREASE! 2023 (Vince Fontaine) Toby’s credits include: Something Rotten (Nick Bottom)Spamalot (Sir Robin), White Christmas (Bob), Godspell, Elf ( Buddy ), Hunchback (Phoebus), A Christmas Story (Old Man), Mamma Mia (Sam), Shrek (Lord Farquaad – Helen Hayes Nomination) among many others. Jeffrey toured the US and Canada in productions [...]

Lynne R. Sigler LYNNE R. SIGLER (Sister Mary Lazarus) Thirty-four years performing in the Baltimore/Washington area. A Toby’s staple since 1986, most recently in It’s A Wonderful Life (2015) and Memphis (HH Nom-2014), Lynne is now ready for the Convent! “Larry, Ross, Mark, Toby, Vickie…Thanks!”

Susan Thornton It's A Wonderful Life 2022 (Mrs. Hatch) Susan is so grateful to be in her 6th production of It’s A Wonderful Life. She thanks Toby, Mike Tilford and David Nehls for creating this heartwarming adaptation 33 years ago. Other Toby’s credits: Funny Girl, Guys and Dolls, The Wizard of [...]

AJ Whittenberger It's A Wonderful Life 2022 (Harry Bailey) 32nd Toby’s show. Happy to be returning to It’s A Wonderful Life. National Tour: Big Nate. Regional: Signature, Bucks County Playhouse, Studio Theatre, Media Theatre, Imagination Stage, Adventure Theatre. By Day: CFO of Carbone Entertainment, Tax Analyst at H&R Block. White Christmas [...]

Gavin Willard Peter Pan 2016- (Michael) is excited to be in Peter Pan! He has been seen in It’s A Wonderful Life (Young George), Ragtime (Edgar), The Addams Family (Pugsly) and Mary Poppins (Michael). He is also a member of The Young Columbians. Enjoy the show!

Samantha Bloom Yakaitis It's A Wonderful Life 2015-(Young Mary/Janey) A “seasoned” performer at 12 years old, favorite roles include: Jane (Mary Poppins), Young Fiona (Shrek) & Cosette (Les Miz). Sam is a member of the Young Columbians with Toby Orenstein. Thanks to Toby, Tina, Vickie, and Ross for another opportunity to [...]