Caroline Otchet Biography coming soon...

Lilianna Robinson LILIANNA ROBINSON (Susan) is excited to perform in her second Toby’s production. She was previously seen as Zuzu in It’s a Wonderful Life. She has also performed in CCTA’s production of Pippin, as well as Glenelg High School’s Seussical and The Music Man. Lilianna is in the 4th grade [...]

Matthew Schleigh It's A Wonderful Life 2015- (George Bailey) is grateful to reprise this role from 9 years ago! Toby’s credits: The Buddy Holly Story, Ragtime, West Side Story, Damn Yankees. DC area credits: Everyman, Ford’s, Shakespeare, Olney,  and Constellation Theatres, Imagination Stage, and others. Training: Catholic University, London Dramatic Academy. [...]

Jeffrey Shankle -ELF The Musical (Buddy) Won a 2024 Helen Hayes award for his performance in Something Rotten (Nick Bottom). Other performances include The Music Man (Harold Hill), The Sound of Music (Captain Von Trapp), 1776 (John Adams), Shrek (Lord Farquaad - Helen Hayes nomination), and many others! He has performed in [...]

Lynne R. Sigler -SISTER ACT 2023 (Sister Mary Lazarus) This Toby’s veteran is glad to be back in “the-round” as the rappin’ nun and working with talented performers, musicians, technicians, and crew. If not for Toby Orenstein giving me a chance in 1986, I would not have been part of this [...]

Susan Thornton It's A Wonderful Life 2022 (Mrs. Hatch) Susan is so grateful to be in her 6th production of It’s A Wonderful Life. She thanks Toby, Mike Tilford and David Nehls for creating this heartwarming adaptation 33 years ago. Other Toby’s credits: Funny Girl, Guys and Dolls, The Wizard of [...]

AJ Whittenberger -MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET (Alvin) 12th consecutive holiday show at Toby's! National Tour: Big Nate. Regional: Signature, Bucks County Playhouse, Studio, Media, Imagination, Adventure, Constellation, Riverside, NextStop, New Candlelight, Compass Rose, Pines, Spooky Action, Lazy Susan, WOB. CFO of Carbone Entertainment Inc. Tax Analyst at HR Block. -It's [...]

Gavin Willard Peter Pan 2016- (Michael) is excited to be in Peter Pan! He has been seen in It’s A Wonderful Life (Young George), Ragtime (Edgar), The Addams Family (Pugsly) and Mary Poppins (Michael). He is also a member of The Young Columbians. Enjoy the show!

Samantha Bloom Yakaitis It's A Wonderful Life 2015-(Young Mary/Janey) A “seasoned” performer at 12 years old, favorite roles include: Jane (Mary Poppins), Young Fiona (Shrek) & Cosette (Les Miz). Sam is a member of the Young Columbians with Toby Orenstein. Thanks to Toby, Tina, Vickie, and Ross for another opportunity to [...]