Janine Sunday -ELF The Musical 2025 (Emily Hobbs) Four-time Helen Hayes nominee. Toby’s credits include: 9to5 (Violet), Something Rotten (Bea), The SpongeBob Musical (Sandy), Spamalot (Lady of the Lake), Into the Woods (Witch), Aida (Amneris), Cats (Grizabella), Miss Saigon (Kim), Jekyll and Hyde (Lucy), West Side Story (Maria). Favorite role: Mom [...]

Patricia 'Pep' Targete -The Wizard Of Oz  2026 (Ensemble) Actor, choreographer & dance teacher. Toby’s: Rock of Ages, The Music Man, 9to5, Disney’s Beauty and the Beast, A Chorus Line, Sister Act, Something Rotten, Ghost, Rocky, Spamalot, White Christmas, The Bodyguard, Ragtime, Memphis, The Color Purple. Regional credits: Maine State Music [...]

AJ Whittenberger -MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET (Alvin) 12th consecutive holiday show at Toby's! National Tour: Big Nate. Regional: Signature, Bucks County Playhouse, Studio, Media, Imagination, Adventure, Constellation, Riverside, NextStop, New Candlelight, Compass Rose, Pines, Spooky Action, Lazy Susan, WOB. CFO of Carbone Entertainment Inc. Tax Analyst at HR Block. -It's [...]

Rachel Kemp White Christmas 2021 (Ensemble) Rachel is excited to be back on stage at Toby’s! Recent shows include Grease, The Bodyguard, and A Christmas Story. Love to AJ, family, and God.

Gavin Willard Peter Pan 2016- (Michael) is excited to be in Peter Pan! He has been seen in It’s A Wonderful Life (Young George), Ragtime (Edgar), The Addams Family (Pugsly) and Mary Poppins (Michael). He is also a member of The Young Columbians. Enjoy the show!

Samantha Bloom Yakaitis It's A Wonderful Life 2015-(Young Mary/Janey) A “seasoned” performer at 12 years old, favorite roles include: Jane (Mary Poppins), Young Fiona (Shrek) & Cosette (Les Miz). Sam is a member of the Young Columbians with Toby Orenstein. Thanks to Toby, Tina, Vickie, and Ross for another opportunity to [...]