Kevin McAllister Ragtime 2015- (Coalhouse Walker) is excited to be returning to Toby’s for this amazing production. It’s an honor to tell this story every night with this amazing cast. Special thanks and love to Toby, Larry, Ilona, Ross, Kate, and Vickie for this opportunity.
Shane McCauley Shrek 2014- (Pinocchio/Ens) is thrilled to be in such a talented cast. Last show at Toby’s was Hairspray (Sketch) at the Baltimore location. Big thanks to Kevin, Larry, Doug, Pam, Shea, for putting this show together! “Love to all my family and friends who support what I LOVE”. [...]
Sean McComas Hairspray 2016 (Brad) is thrilled to debut at Toby’s! Credits include: Olney: The Little Mermaid (Flounder), Nextstop: Into the Woods (Jack) & The Secret Garden (Dickon), Bay Theatre: Master Harold and the boys…(Hally), The Foreigner (Ellard), & Adventure Theatre: Miss Nelson is Missing (Adam)
Calvin McCullough Shrek 2014- (Donkey) Some Regional credits include: Miss Nelson is Missing- Gregory- Adventure Theatre, In The Heights- graffiti Pete- Toby’s, Snowy Day- Harold/ Arnold- Adventure Theatre, A Raisin in the Sun- George Murcheson, Peter and the Wolf- Cat- Imagination Stage, Mirandy and Brother Wind- Brother Wind- Adventure Theatre. [...]
Darren McDonnell The SpongeBob Musical 2022 (Squidward Q. Tentacles) Toby’s credits: Spamalot (Sir Robin - 2015 Helen Hayes Nomination) Mamma Mia (Harry Bright), 1776 (John Dickinson), The Addams Family (Mal Beineke). Regional credits: Anything Goes (US National Tour), Disaster the Musical (Tony - Cockpit), Arsenic and Old Lace (Mortimer - Cockpit), [...]
Brendan McMahon 1776 The Musical (2015)- (Thomas Jefferson) is excited to make his Toby’s debut! He is a graduate from Catholic University’s Drama program. Brendan has recently appeared on stages in D.C. and elsewhere, notably the Williamstown Theatre Festival in their production of June Moon. He would like to thank his [...]
James Mernin -GYPSY 2019 (LA/Bougeron/Ensemble) James is thrilled to be making his Toby’s Dinner Theatre debut! Recent credits include Olney Theatre Center: Elf The Musical (Male Swing/Michael cover); White Plains Performing Arts Center: West Side Story (Tony); Myers Dinner Theatre: She Loves Me (Waiter), The Unsinkable Molly Brown (Prince Delong), Meet [...]
Ariel Messeca -9 to 5 The Musical 2025 (Ensemble, Dick u/s) Upcoming: Drowsy Chaperone (George) at Short North Stage. Credits include: Toby’s - A Chorus Line (Greg), Spamalot, Something Rotten, The SpongeBob Musical, Young Frankenstein, Mamma Mia, The Little Mermaid; Olney Theatre - Beauty and the Beast, Fiddler on the Roof [...]
Abby Middleton - -Disney's The Little Mermaid 2025 (Ariel) Abby is deeply grateful to be back at Toby’s reprising her role as Ariel! Other credits include: American Theatre Group: Parade dir. Hunter Foster (Mrs. Phagan), A Little Night Music starring Kate Baldwin (Charlotte); Arts Center of Coastal Carolina: Company (Jenny); NextStop: [...]