Mackenzie Newbury Mackenzie Newbury (Old Hag/Christmas Future/Ens) is happy to be back after being seen in South Pacific last winter. Area credits include Catch Me if You Can (Brenda Strong), City of Angels (Mallory/Avril), Silence! The Musical (Dream Clarice), 42nd Street and Oklahoma!
Ashley K. Nicholas ASHLEY K. NICHOLAS (Stepp Sister, Ensemble) Ashley is thrilled to be back at Toby’s! Favorite credits include Sister Act (Toby’s), Parade (Keegan Theatre), and Caroline, or Change (Creative Cauldron). Proud graduate of Point Park University’s Conservatory of Performing Arts. As always, much love to her family and friends. [...]
Henry Niepoetter (Jo Jo) Toby’s debut, dream role! Performances at The Kennedy Center, Arena Stage, Ford’s Theatre, Olney Theatre, Constellation Theatre and Adventure Theatre’s James and the Giant Peach (2017 Helen Hayes Award - Outstanding Ensemble). Adventure Theatre MTC Pre- Professional Company Member. Thank you Toby and Mark! [...]
Nurney Shrek 2014- ( Pig #2 / Ens ) Towson U Alum. Toby’s: Spamalot, Miracle on 34th St., The Wiz (Wiz Understudy), & The Color Purple (Bobby). Always let your freak flag fly!
KATELYN O’CONNOR -MEAN GIRLS 2026 (Ensemble, u/s Regina George) Katelyn is excited to make her professional theatre debut! She is a graduate of the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, earningher degree in Dance. Recent dance performance venues include The Kennedy Center with the National Symphony Orchestra, and Baltimore Dance Project, with [...]
Allie O'Donnell Grease 2019 (Frenchy)- Thrilled to be back at Toby’s with this incredible company. Credits Include: Anything Goes (Arena), Big Fish (Keegan), Pippin, Five Lesbians Eating A Quiche (Monumental Theatre), Kiss Me, Kate (Annapolis Shakespeare), Show Boat (Toby’s), Heathers: The Musical, Sweeney Todd (Red Branch). Graduate of Catholic U.Instagram: @the_other_odonnell. [...]
PAYTON O’KEEFE -MEAN GIRL - -MEAN GIRLS 2026 (Aaron Samuels) Payton is thrilled to be making his professional debut in Mean Girls at Toby’s Dinner Theatre. He is grateful for this opportunity. One of his previous credits includes Summer Dinner Theater: Footloose (Willard Hewitt). Payton would like to thank his family [...]
Kadejah One -ROCK OF AGES 2026 (Justice) Recently seen at Toby's in Saturday Night Fever (Candy). Born in New Orleans, LA and a graduate of Bowie State University. National tours: Dreamgirls (Effie White), The Color Purple (Church Lady/Sofia), Rock of Ages (Justice). Kadejah believes that music is a gift from God, [...]
Jamie Ogden Shrek 2014- (Wicked Witch / Ens ) Toby’s : 42 nd Street (Peggy Sawyer), Cats (Jellylorum), White Christmas, Spamalot. DC Area: Compass Rose Theater: The Sound Of Music (Elsa); The Olney Theatre Center: Annie, Grease; Signature Theatre: Company; Imagination Stage: Seussical; Shakespeare Theatre Company: The Two Gentlemen of Verona; [...]
OTEGA OKURUME -SUMMER The Donna Summer Musical 2026 (Andrew Gaines) Toby’s: Mean Girls (Mr. Duvall); ArtsCentric: RENT; NextStop Theatre: Chicken and Biscuits (Reginald/Kenny u/s); Other Voices Theatre: Songs for a New World (Man 1); Spotlighters Theatre: Clyde’s (Montrellous); Silhouette Stages: Evita (Peron u/s), The Lightning Thief (Luke Castallan); 2nd Star Productions: [...]